8/1/18 The Druze Protest Nation Law
There is an old adage — “Don't judge someone, until you've walked a mile in their shoes.” I plead guilty fully internalizing this principle. Ten days ago, the Jewish Nation-State Law was passed. In this column, I made clear I thought it was a bad, unnecessary law that would hurt Israel’s standing in the world. But to be frank, I thought it was just another stupid law the right-wing had passed, which could have some bad legal implications in the future, but the major harm would come from Israel’s image abroad — an image Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, to whom the passage of the law was important, appears to no longer care about, in the age of Trump.
I was wrong. What I, and many in the Israeli public, did not take into account was the reaction of Israel’s non-Jewish minorities to this bill.
The most outspoken against the law have been the Druze. They are a separate ethnic-religious group within the Arab world, who live in Israel, Syria, and Lebanon, and have a long history of being loyal to the country in which they live. Their children have served in the army and the other security services with distinction, since the establishment of the state. They have been forthright in their opposition to the Nation-State bill, calling it “a punch in their gut” — i.e. they who have been loyal to the state are being paid back with a law that discriminates against them. Supporters of the law claim there is nothing in the law that discriminates against non-Jews. Opponents maintain it is not what’s in the law, but what is omitted. Head of the Opposition, former Foreign Minister Tzipi Livni said she had begged Prime Minister Netanyahu to add the line that exists in the Israeli Declaration of Independence, which guarantees equality to all the residents of the country — Netanyahu refused.
The Druze have called for a large demonstration this Saturday night in Tel Aviv’s Rabin Square to protest the Nation-State Law and demand changes. They also established a protest tent in the Square, in advance of the demonstration. To better understand the Druze position, I sat down with one of the organizers of the upcoming rally, Jabber, youth division chairman of the of the fight against the law.
Soon to be married, Jabber is 36 and served for over 10 years in the IDF. He stated: “Passage of the Nation-State Law was a wound to the Druze that should not have been. We scream— we demand change.”
According to Jabber, Netanyahu has created a commission to address their issues. I asked him what are your minimum demands? “Recognition of us and equality; equality of rights.” I asked: “Who should receive equal rights?” Jabber answered: “First, equality of rights for those who fight for it, who are mostly Druze, and rights for every one who defines himself as an Israeli, and for all those who work for the country.” Jabber got a little uncomfortable when I asked him about other citizens of the country who do not necessarily “work” to further their Israeli identity (e.g., Arab Israelis whose identity is more complicated and who, by-and-large, do not serve in the army). He responds that it's not his job to define who receives rights.
Jabber is very careful not to criticize the government. He says the rally is not political and that no political figures will speak at the rally. Jabber hopes the committee appointed by Netanyahu will suggest a change in the law.
As we talk, two individuals join us in the protest tent — one, a wounded veteran who had fought alongside Druze in the army and the second, Dr. Uri Leibowitz, a professor of Philosophy, like his father, the renowned Yeshayahu Leibowitz (who after the Six Day War warned of that war’s disastrous consequences). Both were less optimistic than Jabber, stating they doubted Netanyahu would agree to any changes — as the bill serves him politically — and for him, that’s all that counts.
Away from the square, I spoke to Oded, who is 77 and has lived in Tel Aviv his whole life. I asked him what he thought of the Druze protest. He said he supported it 100%. He did not understand why we needed the Nation-State law or why the government has been passing a whole set of laws that undermine the democratic nature of the state, while continuing to go around contending we are the only democracy in the Middle East.
Earlier in the day, after a similar set of discussions with a number of people, my 25-year-old daughter who is marketing executive asked me why I look bothered. I explained. Her answer, which is equally comforting and disturbing was — “what do you expect. It (nationalism) has taken hold everywhere in the world.” We then went on to discuss why. However, that is for another column.